Every leader, in any organization, faces the same fundamental challenge. You are given a set of human, technological, and financial assets to manage, with the task of making those assets more valuable in tomorrow's world. In short, if you are a leader, your job is to add value. There are two ways to do that. You can use those assets more productively -- deliver more and better goods or services -- and you can grow your assets -- increase their reach and capability.
Growth usually is seen in financial terms -- for good reason in the case of most businesses. If you're competing for capital in the financial markets, you probably have to grow profitably at 12 percent a year and have an operating return on assets of 16 percent a year. According to research by Columbia University Professor Larry Selden, that is what it takes to match the performance of the top quartile of companies in Standard & Poor's 500 stock index. Investment capital is necessary to fund new products and services, and to provide the financial incentives that top technical and management talent demands. But even in the overheated world of Internet start-ups, companies in the long run need growth and profitability. Without growth, the imagination, energy, and investment that companies need will dissipate; without profitability, growth is unsustainable.
Beyond the financial realities, however, growth is important for strategic and psychological reasons. The way you create a vibrant organization is to engage the creativity, energy, and commitment of every member of the enterprise. People need ongoing opportunities to use their skills, try new things, and stretch their limits. Those opportunities are necessary for people to be their best -- and are available in sufficient number only when your organization is growing.
A growth strategy is also the best path toward continual innovation. In education, for instance, there has been an explosion of new models and markets for learning, but most of that activity is happening outside of traditional universities -- in companies, in communities, on the Internet -- where the growth impulse is strongest. If universities don't grow and adapt, they will soon become marginal contributors.
Growth forces you to look at your organization from the outside in -- focusing on what your customers and the environment demand of you. Too many organizations, unfortunately, are managed from the inside out, putting their own practices, policies, or priorities ahead of the needs of customers.
Trilogy Software, which develops sales and marketing systems for large companies, is charting its own route to growth, and creating powerful organizational innovations in the process. Joe Liemandt, its 32-year-old CEO, dropped out of Stanford University to launch the company in 1990. Today Trilogy has nearly 1,000 employees, and his personal stake is worth close to $1 billion.
Liemandt's growth strategy is simply to hire only star performers. He is successfully competing with Microsoft on campus to recruit the best software talent in the world. At the heart of his employee recruitment and development program is Trilogy University, modeled after General Electric's Crotonville management development center. (Liemandt's father worked at GE for many years, and Jack Welch is a close family friend.).
Through his father and Welch, Liemandt saw the impact of stretch objectives, professional development, and open dialogue on workplace performance. But Trilogy takes these beliefs to the limit. The head of Trilogy University, Danielle Rios, has shown that the kinds of programs developed at Crotonville can be pushed much further. Liemandt and Rios work with new college graduates from 8 a.m. until midnight for three months. The students' "action learning" assignment is nothing less than to develop the next generation of products for Trilogy. The program combines R&D and employee development, with weekly evaluations of students' values and performance.
The company hires only 1 in 15 of the people it interviews -- and invests $13,000 in every hire. Yet any recruit whose values or performance do not hold up during the three-month orientation is dismissed -- 6 percent of candidates washed out in a recent Trilogy U. class. And while growth is at the heart of Trilogy's culture, Liemandt does not pursue growth at any price. "We will slow growth down if we find that we're getting close to diluting the quality of our people," he says.
The company uses many mechanisms to support its talent-based growth strategy. For example, each new hire must have a sponsor within the company. If a recruit makes the grade, the sponsor is paid a $1,000 bonus; if he or she fails, the sponsor is fined $4,000. Most sponsors own stock options worth millions of dollars, so $4,000 does not threaten their livelihood. But as one who experienced such a loss reports, "It feels awful. People still give me a hard time about it." Looking back at what went wrong, he adds, "We were pushing to fill head count. I got sloppy, hired a kid who wasn't ready, and he failed. I'm never doing that again."
|
Break the mind-set that high growth is impossible in a mature market. |
Start-ups like Trilogy can make growth seem natural. They are driven by entrepreneurial passion and incentives, and, assuming they survive, have nowhere to go but up. For established organizations, the challenge is to break the mind-set that high growth is impossible in a mature market. Their leaders must make growth a part of the organization's genetic code. Instead of fishing from the same tired waters, they find ways to broaden the pond. The late Roberto Goizuetta reframed Coca-Cola's market opportunity by noting that 5.7 billion people in the world consume 64 fluid ounces of fluid a day -- and that Coke has only 2 percent of that "share of stomach." That's a very different approach from trying to incrementally grow your market share versus a competitor.
Likewise, in 1995, GE Power Systems' Bob Nardelli drew scant comfort from the company's 50 percent share of the $20 billion market for power generation equipment. He saw that the market was stagnant and that deregulation was creating opportunities for new competitors. Nardelli used the acquisition of Italy's Nuovo Pignone not only to expand GE's presence in Europe, but also to enter new market segments in the oil and gas industry. Today GE Power Systems fishes in a $700 billion pond, encompassing the whole value chain of power generation and delivery, from the wellhead to the end user.
The key to such growth is to serve the new and existing needs of both new and existing customers (see figure). Organizations that satisfy themselves just with serving the current needs of current customers inevitably stagnate. The growth matrix suggests three alternative strategies: filling new needs for existing customers, existing needs for new customers, or new needs for a whole new set of customers. These strategies are simple to conceptualize but difficult to execute. They require you to search not just the external environment but the soul of your organization. New market needs can be identified by looking beyond your (and your industry's) current way of doing business, understanding how customers actually use your products or services, and anticipating changes in the market. New customers may be identified in terms of geography, demographic segment, or market segment.
By 1989, Reynolds and Reynolds based in Dayton, Ohio, had seen the effects of ill defined growth: 1980s-style conglomeration and overseas expansion had sapped its strength and focus. New CEO Dave Holmes believed growth was still the answer, but with a different approach. Working
in a mundane industry (printed business forms) and an uncertain one (computer systems for car dealers), the company moved from quadrant A to quadrant D of the growth matrix. Serving new needs of existing customers was the easiest path, and the one most likely to yield quick market insight. Reynolds and Reynolds developed systems that integrate car dealers' sales, parts, service, vehicle registration, document retrieval, and customer follow-up functions. It also provides consulting, training, and marketing services.
Revenue grew to $1 billion in 1996, from $600 million in 1991 -- with profits growing at a compound annual rate of 36 percent. The company's return on equity exceeds 25 percent.
Holmes supported growth with new planning, goal setting, communications, compensation, and training mechanisms. He also recruited executives from much bigger firms, including Motorola, Procter & Gamble, and Xerox, to bring "new genes" and fresh perspective for the founding-family shareholders who largely set the agenda. With its expertise in information systems management, the company has expanded the pond further to include a new set of customers -- physician groups and health care delivery systems.
Focus: Hope in Detroit understands the growth matrix as well as any corporation. The organization was founded by Father William Cunningham and Eleanor Josaitis in response to the Detroit riots of 1968. The most pressing need they saw at the time was hunger -- malnourished infants lose as much as 20 percent of their brain power, which may never return. Focus: Hope's food distribution program became the model for the federal Women, Infant and Children program and now delivers food to 80,000 people a month.
Cunningham and Josaitis then stepped up the value chain and asked how to keep people off food lines. The answer, of course, pointed to a huge new need -- jobs. They scanned the environment and saw an opportunity to train machinists for Detroit's auto makers and suppliers. But they soon realized that their customers, the incoming students, often lacked the math and English skills to run complicated machines.
So Focus: Hope developed a fast track program that took students from 7th-or 8th-grade-level math and English skills to 10th-grade level in just seven weeks. The program combines total immersion with tough love -- anyone who is late, absent, or on drugs is out. After gaining experience in secondary education, Focus: Hope saw similar needs for yet another set of customers -- and founded a Montessori school and teacher training program to serve preschool- and primary school-age children. From there the group created a Center for Advanced Technology that offers associate's, bachelor's, and master's level certification. To prove the value of their training, and develop a steady job market for graduating students, Focus: Hope established several for-profit businesses serving corporate clients.
Of course, growth carries certain risks and burdens. That was evident early in 1999 when the share price of Dell Computer dropped nearly 25 percent -- and brought other high-tech stocks with it -- because the company missed Wall Street's expectations for growth. (The company grew by "only" 38 percent from the prior year, not the 56 percent investors had come to expect.) That may seem like an extreme reaction, but when your stock trades at an astounding 100 times your per-share earnings, you have to deliver, or face severe consequences. Indeed, Compaq Computer encountered a similar decline, for similar reasons, several weeks later. The failure to meet investors' continuously rising expectations cost CEO Eckhard Pfeiffer his job -- despite years of phenomenal growth.
|
You cannot set high growth targets and then simply wish for the best. |
You cannot set high growth targets and then simply wish for the best.As any business leader knows -- or soon finds out -- you cannot set high growth targets and then simply wish for the best. You can achieve fast growth only with competent people, capable systems, and disciplined leadership. Leaders have to be prepared, as Joe Liemandt was, to say they will not push growth beyond the capacity of people to deliver the quality that customers demand.
It is possible to buy growth through mergers and acquisitions, as we have seen in recent years. But that strategy, too, has its limits. Ford's acquisition of Volvo, for instance, adds several billion dollars to corporate revenues, but that by itself does little to help the people running the F-150 truck or Taurus businesses. They still have to grow their own organizations. Therefore Jacques Nasser, Ford's CEO, is driving for a behavioral shift that permeates the organization.
A one-dimensional obsession with growth also takes a toll on the quality of life for workers, their families, and communities. To sustain any institution into the 21st century, leaders must balance many competing interests, and expand their view of the organization's role in society. For example, Ford's Business Leadership Implementation, a three-day workshop for 55,000 employees taught by 1,500 managers, includes a half-day of community service. Nasser supports that investment because he sees the business benefits of an engaged workforce, and because he sees growth -- financial, professional, and social -- as essential to the company's future.
To add value to your assets, you need a vision of where you're taking the institution and a strategy for getting there. You have to paint a clear picture of your destination and the route. That may require a total transformation of the organization, especially when past practices and assumptions forestall growth.
Successful leaders of such journeys are invariably creative thinkers. They know how to look from the outside in, to challenge the status quo, to move proactively, and spot and cultivate talent. They translate their vision of the future into what I call a teachable point of view. This has four elements:
- Ideas -- the products, services, markets, distribution channels, or customer segments that are going to be most important
- Values -- the behaviors and ideals that support those business ideas
- Emotional energy -- the drive, communicated to others, to create positive outcomes
- Edge -- an engagement in the business that allows leaders to make tough, yes-or-no decisions
All of these are essential to asking the right questions about the future and to formulating and implementing a growth strategy. A teachable point of view, grounded in an understanding of your mission, also helps you know when to say no to people, practices, and opportunities that no longer add value to the work of the organization.
The leaders of Focus: Hope, for instance, adhere to a clear point of view and mission each step of the way -- to provide intelligent, practical solutions to poverty and racism, and to respect the dignity of all people. They stay in touch with the needs of the marketplace and are constantly finding new opportunities to add value. Yet they say no to a lot of things. For example, casinos are coming into Detroit, promising to hire inner-city workers. The casinos asked Focus: Hope to train everyone from construction workers to card dealers. Focus: Hope declined, because it would have diverted their resources from the group's primary task. With the death of Father Cunningham in 1997, Focus: Hope also learned that with growth, an organization can flourish even after a leader is gone. Today their 40 managers are learning a disciplined, mission-based budgeting process that is helping them continue to grow the organization.
|
Growth is always a tool, never an end in itself. |
Trilogy, GE, Compaq, Focus: Hope, and hundreds of other high-growth enterprises are demonstrating another lesson: that when an organization is growing, its people are too. For these organizations, growth is always a tool for accomplishing more, never an end in itself. Their leaders know that growth entails risk, but that growing is less risky than not growing. It is part of the genetic code of all living systems, and must become so for all organizations. Like all living systems, organizations that are not growing cannot survive.
Copyright © 1999 by Noel M. Tichy. Reprinted with permission from Leader to Leader, a publication of the Leader to Leader Institute and Jossey-Bass.
Print citation: Tichy, Noel M. "The Growth Imperative" Leader to Leader. 14 (Fall 1999): 24-29.
Permission to copy: Send a fax (+1-201-748-6008) or letter to John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Permissions Department, 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030 USA. Or online at http://www.wiley.com/go/permissions.
Include: (1) The publication title, author(s) or editor(s), and pages you'd like to reprint; (2) Where you will be using the material, in the classroom, as part of a workshop, for a book, etc.; (3) When you will be using the material; (4) The number of copies you wish to make. To subscribe to Leader to Leader: Call +1-888-378-2537 (or +1-415-433-1740). |